Last updated:
Jan. 7, 2004

Site Map:

Back to Home

Courses and Syllabi


Classroom Policies


Links of Interest

Student Projects

Dr. Laura L. Runge
Office: CPR 301J
Phone: 813-974-9496
Office hours: S 04
T 1-2pm; Th 2-4pm;
And By Appt.

Contact Me
with questions,

ENL 3230
British Literature 1616-1780

NOTES on the Happy Critic
Recommended reserve reading

Reading Assignment:

    The Happy Critic: Introduction and chapters 1 & 2
*** Read Chapter 7 of The Happy Critic as soon as possible.

The readings I have assigned in Birenbaum's Happy Critic are important introductory readings which will greatly aid your understanding of the literature for this class and will also lay a good foundation for all your British literature courses.

These will be especially helpful for those of you who have not had any upper-level literature courses, or who have been out of the classroom for some time. The book is an easy-to-read and spirited (sometimes even a bit cor ny) introduction to the principles of reading and writing critically about literature. In it you will find fundamental and advanced concepts which we will use throughout the semester.

Reading Notes:
The Happy Critic:

In his "Introduction" Harvey Birenbaum addresses the reader (you) as a serious reader of literature and offers a vision of literature as a meaningful part of your life.

"The 'happy critic,' then, takes the task of criticism as serious pleasure, a pleasure that involves one's self-awareness, one's sense of reality as a human being in the world, one's passion to know the features of life and art, one's friendly capacity to mingle with other minds. Such pleasure includes frustrations, difficulties, and uncertainties, but it comes from dealing honestly with the richness of literature. It reflects the excitment of reading with satisfaction as one grasps the nature and signi ficance of what one has read" (3).

What I like about Birenbaum's approach to the study of literature is that he invites us to open our minds as well as our emotional selves to the experience of literature, to relate to it through an open and honest investigation, a quest to learn and to experience that will have a meaningful effect on who we are and how we understand our world.

As you read these chapters, try to keep the spirit of Birenbaum's endeavor in mind, and take away as much as you can from the ideas he has to share. On the other hand, do not be afraid to question his ideas if they strike you as fundamentally unsound. There are definitely parts of his philosophy that I do not find palatable. On the whole, however, he provides an excellent introduction to the study of literature.


Chapter One: Thinking about literature

As you read this chapter, keep in mind the example of Addison's poem to begin to understand how some of Birenbaum's concepts might apply to Eighteenth-century British Literature.

NOTE: The distinction between naive readers and sophisticated readers is very important. It is my goal to have every student reading at a more sophisticated level than he or she is upon beginning the course. Where do you fall now? Honestly try to evaluate how you respond to literature right now. How can you become a more sophisticated reader?

In this chapter Birenbaum lays out some very instructive tips for writing and thinking about literature. What does he suggest that you never thought of before? How can you begin to employ some of his ideas in your reading and writing?

"The first requirement of good reading is shrewd observation. . . . We recognized that the details [in literature] are selected (or created) deliberately and follow patterns that the details fall into" (9).

This is a crucial step. Read carefully and observe the details that the author uses to tell his or her story.

Tone is a very significant aspect of a literary work. What does Birenbaum say about discovering the tone of a work? What does he mean when he says "the tone of a work lies in the particular attitude toward life that it expresses"? (11).


NOTE: On page 11 he begins to list the fundamental activities involved in writing a critical paper -- Representation, Interpretation or commentary, Analysis, and Evaluation. Learn these and begin to practice them consciously in your writings.

NOTE: Throughout the all-important first chapter, Birenbaum introduces major concepts in literary studies which I will expect you to understand. For instance, be familiar with the meaning of terms like paraphrase, summary, and explication. Generally speaking, the words in bold type should become a part of your literary vocabulary.

NOTE: Birenbaum also provides some excellent ideas for developing your critical essays: questions to ask, points of departure, perspectives to consider. Review these if you become "stuck" in your own critical writing.


Of the many useful ideas Birenbaum posits, his explanation of interpretation is particularly relevant. Interpreting literature may seem like a mystical discovery of hidden meanings, but let me assure you that meaning in literature (or significance, to us e Birenbaum's preferred term) comes as a result of the conscious artistry of the author and the practiced and sensitive understanding of the reader.

His explanations of terms like allegory, imagery, symbol and their variations should greatly aid your understanding of literature in general.

"Ultimately, all literary works are symbolic, for all represent life with a particular slant, which we interpret" (24).

One of the skills needed for reading eighteenth-century literature is the ability to identify the slant of the author and to determine what symbolic value that has for the work, and for us.

Also take note of his explanation of the "significance" of a work of literature, and in particular avail yourself of his outline of implications.

Pay particular attention to the section on style and genre, because these are issues that greatly concern eighteenth-century authors.


Recall Addison's account of the greatest English poets, and consider Birenbaum's statement: "All writers belong to a literary community. . . . it is a community of contemporaries and also a community of past writers culminating in the present, so that what our author 'mean's' is determined to some degree by the position he or she takes in a larger dialogue" (33).

How does Addison construct his literary community? What are the criteria for inclusion?

Consider Birenbaum's claim that "the writer's style is, by and large, the individuation of a tradition. All this we understand well only by going on reading, expanding our repertoire, or by studying writers in relation to their time period and the sequence of literary history" (33).

What does it mean, then, that it is in the eighteenth-century that writers first begin to account for a literary tradition? How might this explain the impulse toward categorization? Toward imitation of past authors? Toward stylization?

Because the literature of this course is very stylized, it will be especially helpful for you to review Birenbaum's explanation of conventions.


NOTE: Generally speaking, I am less enamored of schematics than Birenbaum apparently is. I do not find such reductive models very useful. I suggest that you use them only to the extent that you find them helpful. Do not rely on them.


Chapter 2: Understanding Understanding: How Valid is Interpretation?

In this chapter, Birenbaum addresses some enduring doubts that students express about the process of learning to understand literature in a sophisticated way.

He begins with the premise -- that I share -- that literature is communication, and to that extent it is a worthy exercise to try and understand its significance, despite the slippery nature of "meaning."

Birenbaum: "Instead of asking why authors did things the way they did . . . it is often safer to ask what effects they have achieved by doing what they did" (44).

Allow me to underscore this suggestion; it will lead you to more productive lines of thought in your understanding literature.


Birenbaum emphasizes the insights that literature induces, or experiential knowledge. He stresses that such observations into the way life works help us to better know ourselves, and vice versa that better knowledge of ourselves improves our sensitivies to the insights of literature.

I want to emphasize a slightly different point, however. While literature does point us to what is human in human experience, we must be attuned to what is different from us and to the reality that there are multiple experiences of life that are equally valid. In a collaborative classroom, we will work through the differences among readers and see these as an important aspect of experiential knowledge.


NOTE: Make yourself familiar with his distinction between response and reaction, because these are crucial distinctions in literary studies. While response is an open reception of the communication in literature, reaction is a rejection. Try to become aware of your reactions: what makes you close down to communication? What preferences or prejudices do you bring to the reading experience? Knowing your own predisposition can help you guard against hasty reactions and move to a fuller appreciation of literature -- even if you still do not like it.

Finally he addresses the question: who has the right to say what literature means. Although literature can be purposely elusive, we have the right to offer opinions and educated interpretations. To shape the "educated imagination" is one of the objectiv es of this class.

Back to Top of Page

Back to 3230 Syllabus